Backgrounds/Aims This study aimed to compare the outcomes of liver resection (LR) and transarterial chemoembolization (TACE) in patients with multinodular hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) within the Milan criteria who were not eligible for liver transplantation.
Methods We retrospectively analyzed 483 patients with multinodular HCC within the Milan criteria, who underwent either LR or TACE as an initial therapy between 2013 and 2022. The overall survival (OS) in the entire population and recurrence-free survival (RFS) in patients who underwent LR and TACE and achieved a complete response were analyzed. Propensity score (PS) matching analysis was also used for a fair comparison of outcomes between the two groups.
Results Among the 483 patients, 107 (22.2%) and 376 (77.8%) underwent LR and TACE, respectively. The median size of the largest tumor was 2.0 cm, and 72.3% of the patients had two HCC lesions. The median OS and RFS were significantly longer in the LR group than in the TACE group (P<0.01 for both). In the multivariate analysis, TACE (adjusted hazard ratio [aHR], 1.81 and aHR, 2.41) and large tumor size (aHR, 1.43 and aHR, 1.44) were significantly associated with worse OS and RFS, respectively. The PS-matched analysis also demonstrated that the LR group had significantly longer OS and RFS than the TACE group (PS<0.05).
Conclusions In this study, LR showed better OS and RFS than TACE in patients with multinodular Barcelona Clinic Liver Cancer stage A HCC. Therefore, LR can be considered an effective treatment option for these patients.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Survival Prediction and Treatment Decisions in Hepatocellular Carcinoma: A Deep Learning-Based Radiomics Approach Xiaoqin Wei, Jun Xiao, Ying Liu, Chaofeng Yang, Ziren Luo, Mingyue Tang, Xiaowen Chen British Journal of Hospital Medicine.2026;[Epub] CrossRef
Liver resection versus radiofrequency ablation or transarterial chemoembolization for early multinodular BCLC-A hepatocellular carcinoma: a systematic review and meta-analysis Maria F. F. Viana, Arthur A. Braga, Lucas B. Carvalho, Danilo C. M. S. Vasconcellos, Bianca C. M. R. Alexandrino, Felipe J. F. Coimbra Journal of Liver Cancer.2026; 26(1): 157. CrossRef
Low Tumor Burden Predicts Benefit from Transarterial Treatment in Hepatocellular Carcinoma with Extrahepatic Metastasis: A Nationwide Cohort Study Jaejun Lee, Hyun Yang, Keungmo Yang, Ji Won Han, Pil Soo Sung, Jeong Won Jang, Si Hyun Bae Liver Cancer.2026; : 1. CrossRef
A Prospective, Multicenter, Randomized, Noninferiority Trial of Stopad® Versus Tachosil® for Hemostasis After Liver Resection Seung Yeon Lim, Gi Hong Choi, Jin Hong Lim, Ho-Seong Han, Yoo-Seok Yoon, Hae Won Lee, Boram Lee, Yeshong Park, MeeYoung Kang, Jinju Kim, Hyelim Joo, Jai Young Cho Cancers.2025; 17(5): 757. CrossRef
Comparison of initial treatments for resectable hepatocellular carcinoma within Milan criteria: an observational study based on a nationwide survey Sang Jin Kim, Woo Kyoung Jeong, Hyung-Joon Han, Gyu-Seong Choi, Kyun-Hwan Kim, Jongman Kim Annals of Surgical Treatment and Research.2025; 108(5): 279. CrossRef
Comparative analysis of the immediate results of surgical treatment in patients with early (BCLC A) and intermediate (BCLC B) stage hepatocellular carcinoma B. I. Sakibov, D. V. Podluzhnyi, Yu. I. Patyutko, E. A. Moroz, O. A. Egenov, N. E. Kudashkin Surgery and Oncology.2025; 15(2): 52. CrossRef
Artificial intelligence for multi-time-point arterial phase contrast-enhanced MRI profiling to predict prognosis after transarterial chemoembolization in hepatocellular carcinoma Lanlin Yao, Hamzah Adwan, Simon Bernatz, Hao Li, Thomas J. Vogl La radiologia medica.2025; 130(10): 1517. CrossRef
Exploring the role of liver resection as a first-line treatment option for multinodular BCLC-A hepatocellular carcinoma Joo Hyun Oh, Dong Hyun Sinn Journal of Liver Cancer.2024; 24(2): 126. CrossRef
Background/Aims Multiplication of α-fetoprotein, des-γ-carboxy prothrombin, and tumor volume (ADV score) is a surrogate marker for post-resection prognosis of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). This study aimed to validate the predictive power of the ADV score-based prognostic prediction model for patients with solitary huge HCC.
Methods Of 3,018 patients, 100 patients who underwent hepatic resection for solitary HCC ≥13 cm between 2008 and 2012 were selected.
Results The median tumor diameter and tumor volume were 15.0 cm and 886 mL, respectively. Tumor recurrence and overall survival (OS) rates were 70.7% and 66.0% at one year and 84.9% and 34.0% at five years, respectively. Microvascular invasion (MVI) was the only independent risk factor for disease-free survival (DFS) and OS. DFS and OS, stratified by ADV score with 1-log intervals, showed significant prognostic contrasts (P=0.007 and P=0.017, respectively). DFS and OS, stratified by ADV score with a cut-off of 8-log, showed significant prognostic contrasts (P=0.014 and P=0.042, respectively). The combination of MVI and ADV score with a cut-off of 8-log also showed significant prognostic contrasts in DFS (P<0.001) and OS (P=0.001) considering the number of risk factors. Prognostic contrast was enhanced after combining the MVI and ADV score.
Conclusions The prognostic prediction model with the ADV score could reliably predict the risk of tumor recurrence and long-term patient survival outcomes in patients with solitary huge HCCs ≥13 cm. The results of this study suggest that our prognostic prediction models can be used to guide surgical treatment and post-resection follow-up for patients with huge HCCs.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
ADV score plus FDG-PET as preoperative predictors of post-resection prognosis in patients with hepatocellular carcinoma ≥10 cm: a retrospective cohort validation study I-Ji Jeong, Shin Hwang, Byung-Gon Nah, Chul-Soo Ahn, Deok-Bog Moon, Tae-Yong Ha, Gi-Won Song, Dong-Hwan Jung, Gil-Chun Park, Ki-Hun Kim, Woo-Hyoung Kang, Young-in Yoon International Journal of Surgery.2026; 112(5): 11840. CrossRef
Diagnostic and prognostic performance of PAK1 methylation in patients with hepatocellular carcinoma undergoing liver transplantation Shin Hwang, Hyo Jung Ko, Eunyoung Tak, Kyoung-Jin Lee, Yun-Kyu Lee Clinical Transplantation and Research.2026; : 104. CrossRef
Five-year complete remission of super-giant hepatocellular carcinoma with hepatectomy followed by sorafenib plus camrelizumab: A case report Xiao-Qin Zheng, Li-Bo Sun, Wen-Jie Jin, Hui Liu, Wen-Yan Song, Hui Xu, Ju-Shan Wu, Xiao-Jun Wang, Chun-Yan Gou, Hui-Guo Ding World Journal of Gastrointestinal Surgery.2025;[Epub] CrossRef
Limited survival benefit of preoperative transarterial chemoembolization in huge hepatocellular carcinoma due to the prognostic impact of satellite nodules: a retrospective cohort study Byeong-Gon Na, Shin Hwang, Chul-Soo Ahn, Ki-Hun Kim, Deok-Bog Moon, Tae-Yong Ha, Gi-Won Song, Dong-Hwan Jung, Gil-Chun Park, Sang Hoon Kim, Sung-Gyu Lee Annals of Surgical Treatment and Research.2025; 109(3): 194. CrossRef
Early identification of hepatocellular carcinoma patients at high-risk of recurrence using the ADV score: a multicenter retrospective study Shuya Cao, Zheyu Zhou, Chaobo Chen, Wenwen Li, Jinsong Liu, Jiawei Xu, Chunlong Zhao, Yihang Yuan, Zhenggang Xu, Huaiyu Wu, Guwei Ji, Xiaoliang Xu, Ke Wang World Journal of Surgical Oncology.2024;[Epub] CrossRef
ADV score is a reliable surrogate biomarker of hepatocellular carcinoma in liver resection and transplantation Shin Hwang, Dong-Hwan Jung, Gi-Won Song Annals of Liver Transplantation.2023; 3(2): 86. CrossRef